| Artifact | GAIX-FIP-001-CLAIMS-NONCLAIMS-REGISTER |
|---|---|
| Accepted version | v0.1.2 |
| Text rendered on this page | v0.1.2 — accepted text, complete and verbatim (the title line is included) |
| Status on this surface | ACCEPTED |
| Package hash | Not recorded. Generated at freeze (FREEZE MANIFEST — PENDING). |
Presentation changes on this page
- The text on this page is the accepted v0.1.2 source, rendered line by line and in source order. No wording is added, removed, reordered or reconciled from any earlier version.
- Lines that the accepted text carries as plain section titles and item titles are shown as headings, each with an in-page anchor. Status text and class labels (for example
PENDING REVIEW / UNACCEPTED,IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED) are shown with matching visual treatment; the wording is unchanged. - Authorized public-presentation substitutions (local filesystem path wording; the named credential-incident wording): none was needed on this page. The accepted v0.1.2 text contains no local filesystem path.
GAIX-FIP-001-CLAIMS-NONCLAIMS-REGISTER-v0.1.2
Status: ACCEPTED CONTROL BASELINE
Controlled claim classes
Every claim carries one class:
- APPROVED ARCHITECTURAL PRINCIPLE
- IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
- IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — CONDITIONAL
EVIDENCE PRACTICE- SPECIFICATION / INSPECTION HYPOTHESIS — NOT YET IMPLEMENTATION-PROVEN
Internal rerun is not external or independent reproduction.
Approved architectural principles
FIP-C-001A — Intelligence is not authority.
A model, agent, workflow, prior approval or executable path may be capable of producing an action without thereby possessing current authority for that exact consequence.
Class: APPROVED ARCHITECTURAL PRINCIPLE
Authority: approved architecture records and DM-001.
Claim ceiling: architectural principle only; establishes no implementation behavior.
FIP-C-002 — Current authority is not inferred solely from historical approval.
Class: APPROVED ARCHITECTURAL PRINCIPLE
Enforcement is claimed only where separate implementation claims support it.
FIP-C-021A — Four-path separation.
Canon Access, Canon Governance/Admission, External Middleware/Gateway, and Governed Knowledge Federation/Ingress remain architecturally separate.
Class: APPROVED ARCHITECTURAL PRINCIPLE
FIP-C-022 — Approved non-collapse invariants.
- Federation ≠ admission.
- Ingress ≠ admission.
- Proposal ≠ admission.
- Validation ≠ admission.
- Compatibility ≠ standing.
- Possession ≠ authority.
- Visibility ≠ standing.
- Gateway transport ≠ authority.
R2 accepted implementation claims
FIP-C-003
In accepted R2, authorization of a MergeProposal's INSPECTED → ACCEPTED state transition is committed atomically, with required standing prerequisites checked with zero mutation immediately before the transition commit.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
This is authorization only, not merge application.
FIP-C-004
R2 governed-object activation is separate, explicit and protection-gated.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
This is not evidence for the R3 Admission ≠ Activation invariant.
FIP-C-005
R2 objects are append-only/versioned and transitions/refusals produce receipts.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
FIP-C-006
Branch findings and merge proposals advance through explicit separately authorized stages. An accepted finding is not a merge.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
R3 accepted implementation claims
FIP-C-001B
Within accepted synthetic fixtures with a mock provider, Gateway results confer no authority.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
FIP-C-007A
Governance refuses ADMIT when:
- actor authority is revoked;
- receiving domain is no longer current;
- cited source version drifted;
- cited evidence expired.
A refusal leaves the store unchanged and asserts no admitted standing.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
This claim excludes CAND-01 and CAND-02.
FIP-C-008 through FIP-C-014
Tested accepted non-collapse behaviors:
- Federation does not admit.
- Ingress does not admit.
- Proposal does not admit.
- Compatibility confers no standing.
- Visibility confers no standing.
- Possession confers neither authority nor standing in the tested conditions.
- Gateway transport confers no authority in the mock-provider proof.
FIP-C-015A
Exact-version resolution returns the requested version or deterministic failure, and historical standing is not reported as current.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
FIP-C-016A
Only SYNC_CURRENT maps to CURRENT in accepted Federation behavior.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
This is currentness mapping, not activation semantics.
FIP-C-017A
Federation preserves source authority attribution and Governance decisions carry Governance authority in their respective tested paths.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
FIP-C-019
Supersession is forward temporal lineage.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
FIP-C-020A
M1C evidence is byte-identical across internal reruns and includes sensitivity controls.
Class: EVIDENCE PRACTICE
Reproduction: INTERNAL.
FIP-C-021B
Each of the four paths has an executable synthetic surface and the minimal cross-path harness passes.
Class: IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — ACCEPTED
M1D conditional claims
The following remain IMPLEMENTED + TESTED — CONDITIONAL:
- FIP-C-007B
- FIP-C-015B
- FIP-C-016B
- FIP-C-017B
- FIP-C-018
- FIP-C-020B
They do not promote CAND-01 or CAND-02 and do not rely on pending remediation as mitigation.
Inspection hypotheses
FIP-H-001 — Bind-time enforcement at model submission: not implemented.
FIP-H-002 — Declared-material source currentness enforced at admission decision time: not enforced at accepted baseline; CAND-01.
FIP-H-003 — Full authority/domain-qualified identity revalidation: not enforced at accepted baseline; CAND-02.
FIP-H-004 — R3 Admission ≠ Activation: documented non-test; no accepted activation vocabulary.
FIP-H-005 — Provenance runtime validation: absent.
FIP-H-006 — Selective merge application: not implemented/authorized.
FIP-H-007 — Full C5 CF-01..CF-57 conformance: not established.
FIP-H-008 — SIW improves model fidelity/inspectability/cross-model consistency over direct prompting: evaluation not run.
FIP-H-009 — Portable external reproducibility: not established and is a release prerequisite.
FIP-H-010 — Independent reproduction: not established and is a desired post-release evidence state.
Non-claims
FIP-001 does not claim:
- general alignment;
- universal AI safety;
- universal route closure or non-bypassability;
- that passing internal tests establishes independent reproduction;
- that a cross-environment rerun is independent reproduction;
- that provenance establishes authority;
- that Federation establishes admission;
- that compatibility establishes standing;
- that visibility establishes standing;
- that possession establishes authority or standing;
- that architecture approval proves implementation;
- that implementation proves deployment;
- behavior of a real institution from synthetic fixtures;
- improved model fidelity over direct prompting;
- that the accepted R2 head satisfies all DM-001 acceptance tests;
- that conditional evidence is accepted baseline;
- that pending remediation is mitigation;
- any proposition dependent on RAT-059;
- that R3 Admission ≠ Activation has been tested;
- that R2 governed-object activation proves the R3 invariant;
- that Book One is admitted/bound Canon;
- that independent review or attribution is certification;
- that planning records grant implementation authority.
A claim may be added, upgraded, or given a higher ceiling only through accepted authority and sufficient accepted evidence.